Read all my reviews on dinosaur books.
The "Kingfisher Illustrated Dinosaur Encyclopedia" by David Burnie is probably the best for new students, especially with a reading age of 8 to 12 years. The information is accurate and the varied illustrations are of a high quality. However, it doesn't cover the newer discoveries (like the therizonosaurs or dinosaurs with feathers) having been published back in 2001.
Typically, the start of the book designates pages (about 20) to background information. In this case 'Life in the Distant Past' which sets aside two pages on such topics as the beginning of life; Earth's first animals; evolution; fossils: how they form and paeleontology; continental drift; mass extinctions; and time scales. The book then moves into life found from the periods before the Mesozoic (about 30 pages). Dinosaurs take up the bulk of the remainder of the book (110 pages) with flying reptiles, sea reptiles and mammals completing the last 50 pages.
The dinosaur section is divided into dinosaur groups: Plant-eating giants; Ornithopods; Meat eaters; Giant meat-eaters; and Armoured dinosaurs. Each of these sections have a few pages on each of the genus' (eg Megalosaurs and Segnosaurs; Allosaurs; and Tyrannosaurs in the Giant meat-eaters section). Each of these sections provide a paragraph (about 80-100 words) on each species (eg Allosaurus; Carcharodontosaurus; Neovenator; and Giganotosaurus) with a small habitat illustration on most (but not all).
What I like about this book is the balanced viewpoints. Unlike "National Geographic Dinosaur" by Barrett, this book's commentary is much more credible in that it provides both sides of an argument, thus providing information that is accurate instead of dogmatic. The only issue I have is the text is too short. But for a new student, it is just right.
The other point of discussion in dinosaur books are the illustrations. The "Kingfisher Illustrated Dinosaur Encyclopedia" has a lot of illustrations of many kinds: pencil sketches, paintings of individual dinosaurs against a white background, paintings of habitat scenes and photos of fossils. All the illustrations are accurate unlike "Dinosaurus" by Parker and Gee's "A Field Guide to Dinosaurs". Only Raul Martin's illustrations in "National Geographic Dinosaur" are of equal quality.
What I also like about this book is the sketches are often showing relative sizes of species. Without any other point of reference for size (there is no scale anywhere for comparisons) these sketches are really useful.
Another impressive feature of the book are the odd chapters of aspects characteristic to the group. For instance, in
Plant-eating giants the feature is:
'Feeding on Plants' - diet and teeth;
'A Question of Size' - weighing dinosaurs, reaching the top of trees.
Ornithospods:
'Life in a Group' - herd sizes, dinosaur social life;
'Colours and Camouflage' - sex differences, changing colour;
'Sounds' - crests.
Meat-Eaters:
'Moving on Two Legs' - sprinters and plodders, balance;
'Studying Dinosaur Tracks' - gauging speeds, identifying footprints;
'Dinosaur Brains' - nervous systems, relative brain size, learning;
'Parental Care' - incubation, leaving the nest;
'The Origin of Birds' - first feathers, gliding, light for flight.
Giant Meat-Eaters:
'Carnosaurs' - family, limits to growth;
'Were Dinosaurs Warm-Blooded?' - hearts, evidence in bone.
Armoured Dinosaurs:
'Dinosaur Defences' - jaws and claws, whips and clubs, spines and horns, plating;
'Weapons and Ornaments' - sexual selections, locking horns.
Overall, this is a fantastic first book on dinosaurs. The information is reliable and the illustrations very good. It would suit any new student over most other dinosaur books.