I love Coben, I really do: Tell No One proved formative in my decision to write genre fiction. I've proceeded to gobble up every stand-alone since Tell, but by the time I finished No Second Chance, his third stand-alone, I noticed Coben had employed THE VERY SAME TWIST IN EACH BOOK. Tell No One, Gone For Good, No Second Chance, Just One Look--the big mystery behind each pivoted on the same identical fulcrum. I wondered: "Will he ever try something new?"
Enter The Innocent. I prayed and begged the gods of genre fiction that Coben had learned to flex his creative muscles. I bequeathed them burnt offerings as an intercession on Coben's behalf, that they would let the scales fall from his eyes and grow him to be more than a one-trick pony. Please, I wailed, please let The Innocent be different! No more of the same!
But the gods must hate me.
The Innocent has at its core the same schtick peddled in previous Coben stories which, for the sake of not spoiling your own reading, will not be mentioned in this review. The story had the twists and turns Coben's fans have come to expect, but in the end it seems he's grown quite content to re-gift the same gimmick to us time and again. Not only that, but The Innocent was his second most sloppily-written work behind Just One Look. His description resorts yet again to little more than telling as opposed to showing. The characters are better drawn here than in Look, the ever-present info-dump still frustrates--albeit not as madly as in Look--and the dialogue continues to be embellished and redundant. Furthermore, instances exist when the story FEELS like it's moving forward, but ends up staying in one place till the next chapter or the one after that. Comparatively speaking, Innocent was a welcome semi-return to form after Just One Look (a putrid piece of fiction). It doesn't stand up to Tell, Gone, or even Chance, or even most of the Bolitar series, but thank the fiction gods that at least we don't have to put up with Just One Look II: The Sideways Glance.
The message seems to be, "I'm Harlan Coben, I can take you for a ride, so I can grow lax in the areas not concerned with plot." He's since returned to his Bolitar series, and for that we can only hope his schtick has at last come to an end. Read this after Tell, Gone, and Chance (in that order), and skip Look. Be prepared, however, that the more you read his stand-alones the more you'll get the same ol' again and again.