|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||
よく一緒に購入されている商品
登録情報
|
この商品を見た後に買っているのは？
この商品にタグをつける(詳細)タグは、商品との関連性が非常に強いキーワードまたはラベルのようなものです。
タグにより、すべてのお客様がお気に入りの商品の整理と確認を行うことができます。 ※タグは初期設定で公開になっています。詳しくはこちら |
カスタマーレビュー
Amazon.com で最も参考になったカスタマーレビュー (beta)
Amazon.com:
4件のカスタマーレビュー
10 人中、9人の方が、｢このレビューが参考になった｣と投票しています。
Problems exposed, but solutions not revealed,
2010/12/17
形式:ペーパーバック|Amazonが確認した購入
As a fan of Tony Koester,I have to say I found this book disapointing. While it takes you through prety well all the moments of decision,no where does it list a clear plan of approach to directing your efforts to produce the DREAM layout. From my own modest experience I think it would have been more helpful to outline some of the beginners errors such as the problems relating to tight number 4 turnouts, the fact that wagons/cars etc have changed over time, and how to detect which are correct for your chosen time period. I believe it would have been wise to suggest joining a club, and being prepaed to ask questions , would have been good advice.
In addition, some discussion on subjects such as running trains versus prototype operations to some degree would be helpful to the more modest beginners.
Experienced model railroaders to whom this book may have been directed. probably have already learnt the hard way, and made the necessary decisions needed to solve the problems he mentions.
In addition, some discussion on subjects such as running trains versus prototype operations to some degree would be helpful to the more modest beginners.
Experienced model railroaders to whom this book may have been directed. probably have already learnt the hard way, and made the necessary decisions needed to solve the problems he mentions.
3 人中、3人の方が、｢このレビューが参考になった｣と投票しています。
Any railroader must have this!
2011/1/19
形式:ペーパーバック
Model Railroading from Prototype to Layout is a 'must' for any model railroader interested in modeling a specific prototype railroad. From researching real railroads for models to designing a layout based on prototype principles and operating a model railroad, this is packed with examples of research strategies, design principles, and model railroad construction. Any railroader must have this!
2 人中、2人の方が、｢このレビューが参考になった｣と投票しています。
Interesting
2011/7/28
形式:ペーパーバック
This book is a bit different than most published by Kalmbach. It's not a how-to book and it's not a project book. It's more of what I'd call a "model railroading philosophy" book.
I felt this was a good book which contained good thoughts but it wasn't quite what the title makes it out to be. Given "Prototype to Layout" you'd think this was a type of how-to book, giving you steps on how to start with history and factual data about a railroad then how to turn that into a layout and operation plan. It has some pieces of that, but overall I didn't feel that's what the book was. It's not a how-to.
Instead this book covers a lot of thoughts and perspectives, things to consider when designing or thinking about a larger operational layout. It asks questions that make you think. It also makes a few fairly bold and opinionated statements.
Some of these statements you'll likely agree with and others you won't. Here's one that I found particularly polarizing. Koester, reflecting on his process designing his dream NKP railroad comments on the dilemma he faced trying to decide given limited space if he should model the town he fondly remembered as a young boy or the town which was "ugly" but had an interchange yard (universal industry). His conclusion on the matter was something to the effect of, "operational possibilities should never be sacrificed for modeling potential." Depending on your own experience and perspective towards model railroading you may or may not agree with that statement.
Regardless this book is occasionally sprinkled with these polarizing statements. Whatever you might think of them they at least do make you think. Just in case it's sounding like I didn't like the book, I did. There were a few key things it changed about my approach and I suspect in a year or two I will look back and say that it was more influential than I initially realized.
If you're at the stage in your model railroading journey where you've gotten past buying whatever looks cool at your LHS and not thinking accuracy is for collectors and you're ready to spend some time thinking about model railroading and doing some real research and planning based on a prototype but want to be influenced by some ideas of long time model railroading veteran, this is a book you'll want to consider.
I felt this was a good book which contained good thoughts but it wasn't quite what the title makes it out to be. Given "Prototype to Layout" you'd think this was a type of how-to book, giving you steps on how to start with history and factual data about a railroad then how to turn that into a layout and operation plan. It has some pieces of that, but overall I didn't feel that's what the book was. It's not a how-to.
Instead this book covers a lot of thoughts and perspectives, things to consider when designing or thinking about a larger operational layout. It asks questions that make you think. It also makes a few fairly bold and opinionated statements.
Some of these statements you'll likely agree with and others you won't. Here's one that I found particularly polarizing. Koester, reflecting on his process designing his dream NKP railroad comments on the dilemma he faced trying to decide given limited space if he should model the town he fondly remembered as a young boy or the town which was "ugly" but had an interchange yard (universal industry). His conclusion on the matter was something to the effect of, "operational possibilities should never be sacrificed for modeling potential." Depending on your own experience and perspective towards model railroading you may or may not agree with that statement.
Regardless this book is occasionally sprinkled with these polarizing statements. Whatever you might think of them they at least do make you think. Just in case it's sounding like I didn't like the book, I did. There were a few key things it changed about my approach and I suspect in a year or two I will look back and say that it was more influential than I initially realized.
If you're at the stage in your model railroading journey where you've gotten past buying whatever looks cool at your LHS and not thinking accuracy is for collectors and you're ready to spend some time thinking about model railroading and doing some real research and planning based on a prototype but want to be influenced by some ideas of long time model railroading veteran, this is a book you'll want to consider.
これらのレビューは参考になりましたか？
ご意見はクチコミでお聞かせください。
リストマニア
関連商品を探す
同じキーワードの商品を探す
フィードバック
- カタログ情報、または画像について報告
- 著者からのコメント
- 出版社からのコメント
|
