"Mission to Minerva" brought a whole lot memories rushing back when I spotted it on the bookshelves of a bookstore I was browsing through in late November.
James P. Hogan's "Inherit the Stars," "Gentle Giants of Ganymede" and "Giants' Star" were among the first SF novels I'd ever read. Heh. Suffice to say, I purchased "Mission" and, for the most part, don't regret it. What I liked and disliked follow:
LIKES
1. The recap at the beginning of the novel. It was a nice way of refamiliarizing myself with the characters. After all, I hadn't read of Hunt, Danchekker, et al., since the late 1980s!
2. The chronology at the end of the novel. That went far in helping me to visualize the breadth of the "Giants" universe, so to speak. Such huge expanses of time, a good part of which remain a mystery.
3. Getting a closer look at what the societies and governments of Minerva were like. There were times I felt like I was prying (in a good way!) into the affairs of my great-to-the-nth-power grandparents!
4. Learning a bit more about the Giants' former presence on Minerva.
5. VISAR and ZORAC. Need more be said? Yes! Their wisecracks were great!
6. Imares Broghuilio, the leader of the Jevlenese thrown back through time, and his "merry" bunch. It was a hoot to see Broghuilio in action again; I couldn't help but laugh at how he reacted to the circumstances he found himself in, especially toward the end. Classic Broghuilio! Heh. For some reason I kept envisioning Looney Tunes' Yosemite Sam whenever Broghuilio would go off the deep end.
DISLIKES
1. The "hard SF" went a little overboard. While I'm no physicist, neither am I completely unfamiliar with theories involving multiple realities and whatnot. Yet this is what took up a good chunk of the novel - the first half, minimum - and, frankly, it was a challenge to get into the story in the beginning. And, yes, I know Hogan is a "hard SF" writer, so I wasn't going in uninformed. Still ...
2. I wanted more of a character-driven story once the "mission to Minerva" part kicked off. I wanted to know more about the Cerians, the Lambians, Kles, Laisha, et al. Sadly, it wasn't fully to be, but I did savor what meat there was. Also, as another reviewer noted, I had hoped Charlie and Koriel (characters from previous Hogan novels in the "Giants" lineage) would make appearances, but they didn't.
3. While Hogan chose a novel way to excise the Jevlenese, it seemed a bit too "convenient" and quick for me.
CONCLUSION
Overall, Hogan's "Mission" is a solid piece of work. It's not perfect by any means - I counted close to a dozen grammatical errors throughout the novel (publishers really need to pay more attention to copy editing, because this is a trend I've noticed more and more over the last five to 10 years) - but its woes aren't enough to warrant a "no-buy" decision. This is particularly true if you're into the "Giants" series or Hogan's works in general.