Ive come to see the lonely planet books as usefull in three ways. One as a traveling guide, which seems to be its intended function. Atleast when it comes to its books to the middle east it fulfills this role. Second, as a book which provides a nice long summary of the countries with history, culture, paracticalities and interesting information which is essential to read if one is to truly "visit" another country. And finaly, as guides to read in their new editions after one has already visited the place.
For the first two, in general this edition is well to do. Its hard cramming in so much tourist information for so many countries on so few pages. The job is not what to say, but what to leave out. And in eneral the book is updated, usualy more so for prices than information.
However, some things still dont change. For instance, while Baalbek remains one of the most amazing sites to visit, it is paid lip service. While Tehran is a dynimic and changing sunny city, it is consistantly given a rather terrible review.
However, in the name of a good regional guide, it is the only one. The LetsGo guide is a joke...provided books for spoiled western kids to plow the same old tired route as beofre...as they usualy all are.
However, the getting there and away section for this new edition is as terrible as they always are. When people are planning trips they want to know all of their options and a general idea of the costs, its often the first thin readers look at are the costs, easy of getting around and time it takes. The authors of this guide have certainly not put in the hours of painstaking research required to provide this inormation. However, as usual, its the best guide, essential for a relatively short...budget trip, and hey...as always it has a nice glossy cover.
As for a guide to read, after visiting, its great nostalgia, though consistently irritating, far too much coverage is negative, far too many wonderful fun activities are left out. And while I am a budget backpacker, there are always business travelers who use the guide but find it far less useful than it can be. It should be as comprehensive as possible.
Four stars