The Fodor's book excels in helping you find a nice hotel, with lengthy explanations about amenities and location. It only falls short in the general information section, where it can't come close to the Moon Handbook for Tahiti. But as fist mentioned, the Moon book doesn't provide sufficient detail on the properties themselves. Also, don't expect a Lonely Planet-type focus on low-end properties. It's not there. Still, you could easily get by with just the Fodor's book. It has all you need.