Reading about some CEO in the insurance industry, even a colorful one like Hank Greenberg, would not normally be my first choice for spending a leisurely afternoon by the fire. But I am certainly glad I chose to pick up this book.
Ron Shelp's tale of Hank Greenberg and AIG is utterly fascinating. The rise and fall of Greenberg, an extraordinary man who despite his present troubles is obviously greatly admired by the author (a former senior officer of AIG who reported directly to Greenberg for 12 years), has elements of Greek tragedy. At age 80, Greenberg had everything one could possibly want in the world, and he had earned it all. One would think his highest priority should have been to protect his legacy and his well-deserved reputation as one of the world's great businessmen.
But he was tripped up by inattentiveness to his own vulnerability and that of his company in a post-Enron world. The free-wheeling ways of the international insurance industry, and the dubious financial engineering methods and questionable accounting practices that must have been growing like a cancer inside AIG over a number of years, never seemed to have sounded any warning bells in his mind. It was business as usual. But after Enron, the world had changed, and Greenberg had the bad luck to have as an adversary an energetic, determined and effective crusader against corporate malfeasance -- the Attorney General of New York (and now Governor-elect) Eliot Spitzer.
The rest is history. Ongoing litigation will determine the final chapter of this story. Greenberg's alleged misdeeds, even if they are proved in court, are trivial in comparison to the crimes committed at Enron and by many of the more egregious corporate bad guys of our era. Punishment, if the prosecutors prevail, will likely be a lot less severe than in some other high profile cases. But those alleged misdeeds have already been enough to destroy a great man's reputation, and that must be a stunning personal tragedy for the leading character of this excellent book.