While Potter mania peters out in the fantasy literary world, Dragonlance fans were treated with what can only be called a return to the stories that started it all. Dragonlance Chronicles was probably one of the first few stories that introduced us to the world of Krynn. When news came that Weis and Hickman planned to revisit the original trilogy, I was elated but wary at the same time. My trepidation was warranted when I read the first entry of the Lost Chronicles; it was an average Dragonlance story at best but coming from Weis & Hickman, I expected better.
Right of the bat, there are very few scene featuring the Companions. Don't believe the blurbs. Yes, Tassslehoff is back (sigh...) along with grumpy Flint and the emerging Laurana. From what I gathered, the story took place right after Dwarven Depths and runs all the way to the first 3rd of Winter Night; focusing primarily on the other group of Companions adventures in Icereach and the political intrigue and rise of Kitiara.) The relationship between the 3 primary protagonists Knights (first introduced in Winter Night: Derek Crownguard, Brian Donner & Aran Tallbow), and later Sturm Brightblade, is a microcosm of the schism engendered by the Solamnics in this era. The authors did a great job fleshing out the said Knights (aside from Derek & Sturm, the other Knights had paltry roles in Winter Night) as multi-dimensional characters rather than the archetypes we are all too familiar with. Kitiara... is still Kitiara. Those hoping to read more about her and Soth will be disappointed. The venerable Lord Soth appears in one chapter at the start of the book and 3 chapters at the end of the book while Kit spends most of the novel plotting and scheming her way to ever-more dizzying heights of power and of course, obsessing over Tanis (who can resist a red head?). Simply put, the authors could've done more with Soth than cameo the poor fellow.
As with any Weis and Hickman novels, it's the side characters that often catch my attention. Toede makes his groveling appearance while Ariakas is still a tower of power. The scheming witch Iolanthe is too similar to Kitiara but the Aesthetics the knights met in Tarsis are a breath of fresh air. Again, too bad the authors did not make full use of the other Highlords that made cameo appearances that were all too brief. Feal-Thas, the primary antagonist, is markedly different from the megalomaniacal villains that reside in every pocket of Krynn. He's intelligent, aloof, cold, calculating, powerful and vicious. His agendas are murky but his reasoning and thoughts are smartly translated. With some touch-ups, he could have been a memorable Dragonlance villain.
Most readers will have no doubt know how this story ends (if you don't... well, piece it together.) That being said, I found myself wondering about the what-ifs as I read the novel; what if some one DID NOT do that or happen on THAT? You've got to give Weis and Hickman for threading together multiple ongoing story lines that interweave in this period. References to past events and ominous portents of things to come are liberally scattered throughout the book, making it a joy to read and recollect some of the past and future stories IF you have been an avid fan. The authors even included a little reference page at the end to help sort out some (but not all) aspects of the narrative. I considered the writing style for the Dwarven Depths to be ham-handed and clunky but the authors have refined the prose in this volume. The pacing was generally acceptable but it seemed rushed towards the end. That is frankly disappointing because by golly, THE FIRST MEETING BETWEEN LORD SOTH AND KITIARA merited more than just 18 pages. What a waste of literary exposition.
So, why 4 stars? Despite my criticisms, most of us will enjoy this book for what it is: a trip down memory lane. How many of us were thinking this while reading any of the Lost Chronicles: What we were doing and where we were when we first read the original Chronicles?