Finally an almost complete guide for Bishop and surrounding area!
Pro: Great pictures, clear layout of many of the popular routes in the area. Overall great description. I don't have any problems finding what I want to do. This book included enough routes for you to do in months. Also it includes bouldering areas around Bishop such as Rock Creek.
Cons: As expected, some errors of index and references. Such as route number on the picture is not corresponding to the description. Some reference number on the overall area map is incorrect as well. They can be easily figured out though. Also, the graphic layout is different between the main Bishop area and the surrounding area, my guess is that it was done by different graphic artist, or at different time. It should have been more consistent.
I believe the 2nd edition will be perfect!